facebook pixel
Neal Shulman
Neal Shulman
Neal Shulman

What Podcasters Look for in a Guest: Key Metrics That Matter

March 31, 2025
What Podcasters Look for in a Guest: Key Metrics That Matter

In the ever-evolving world of digital content, podcasts have emerged as powerful platforms for sharing knowledge, connecting with audiences, and establishing authority. Whether you're an entrepreneur, author, or marketing professional, finding the right podcast to showcase your expertise can be transformative. In this blog post, we delve into ten top-tier podcasts that offer exceptional opportunities for guests to expand their reach and share their insights with engaged audiences. From business growth strategies to crafting compelling content, these podcasts cover a wide array of topics that cater to diverse interests and niches.

1. Leverage Your Podcast Show

Leverage Your Podcast Show, hosted by Lyndsay Phillips, is a must-listen for podcast hosts and guests eager to unlock the secrets of podcasting success. Each episode dives into strategies for boosting visibility and growing businesses through effective podcasting techniques.

Why pitch: A guest spot offers exposure to an audience eager for insights on podcast growth strategies.

Ideal guests: Entrepreneurs, podcast strategists, and industry experts with innovative approaches to podcasting.

Why we love it: The show's commitment to actionable insights and Lyndsay's enthusiasm make it a beloved resource.

2. Book Marketing Mania

Book Marketing Mania, hosted by Kim Stewart, supports nonfiction authors in growing their platforms and engaging with readers. Focused on leveraging podcasting for book marketing, it emphasizes long-term strategies aligned with Christian values.

Why pitch: Connect with a broad audience of authors and entrepreneurs seeking guidance on building their platforms.

Ideal guests: Nonfiction authors who have used podcasting to enhance their book marketing efforts.

Why we love it: Its guidance on expanding reach through podcasting makes it indispensable for authors.

3. Insider Secrets to a Top 100 Podcast

Hosted by Courtney Elmer, this podcast is a game-changer for business owners aiming to elevate their podcasting success. It merges human behavior science with podcasting strategies.

Why pitch: Join high-profile guests and amplify credibility and visibility.

Ideal guests: Thought leaders and experienced podcasters with insights into podcasting psychology.

Why we love it: The comprehensive roadmap to podcast success keeps listeners coming back for more.

4. Better Brave: Your Podcasting Mentor

Hosted by Candace Dudley, this podcast is rich in resources for podcasters looking to elevate their craft. It blends strategies and real-world tips to help listeners launch and sustain impactful podcasts.

Why pitch: Ideal for sharing expertise with a dedicated audience of passionate podcasters.

Ideal guests: Experts in podcasting, entrepreneurship, or personal development.

Why we love it: Its authentic approach and motivational content inspire listeners.

5. Podtastic Audio

Chris Smith hosts this podcast offering budget-friendly advice on creating professional-sounding content. It's a guide for indie podcasters aiming for high-quality audio without draining their wallets.

Why pitch: Share expertise with a broad audience of indie podcasters and hobbyists.

Ideal guests: Experienced podcasters and audio engineers with practical advice on audio quality.

Why we love it: Its commitment to practical solutions makes it a trusted resource.

Conclusion

These podcasts offer unparalleled platforms for sharing expertise, expanding influence, and connecting with diverse audiences. By leveraging these opportunities, guests can amplify their voices and make meaningful contributions to the podcasting community. Whether you're a seasoned expert or an emerging thought leader, consider pitching to these shows and watch your influence grow.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is MagicPitch?

Minus iconMinus icon

MagicPitch is a software that leverages the world's best databases, incredible PR expertise, and AI to automatically create media lists & draft pitches on your behalf.

How does MagicPitch work?

Minus iconMinus icon

You sign up for a MagicPitch account and upload the information of whomever you want to pitch to podcasts. Then, watch as MagicPitch populates thousands of active & relevant podcasts in front of your eyes. In just a click of a button, MagicPitch will draft fully customized emails that you can send to the podcast with a click of a button.

Is MagicPitch secure with my email?

Minus iconMinus icon

Yes. MagicPitch-sent emails have a spam rate that's 15X lower than the average email. We use best-in-class security mechanisms to safeguard your information. Your info is never used to train anyone else's account.

How much does it cost? Is there a commitment?

Minus iconMinus icon

MagicPitch offers a $99 trial for unlimited pitching for one month. You can get a quote during any live demo that you book with our team.

How many podcasts do you have?

Minus iconMinus icon

Our daily-updating database contains all 3.85 million English-speaking podcasts. No exceptions.

How much time does it take per week to use MagicPitch?

Minus iconMinus icon

The average MagicPitch user spends less than 30 minutes per week on the platform to send up to 750 emails out per week on average.

Do you guarantee podcast appearances?

Minus iconMinus icon

The average MagicPitch user scores 7-9 podcasts booked per month for every person pitched via the platforn.

As you may know, there are no coverage guarantees in PR. However, we will contractually guarantee you'll have a better success rate than pitching them on your own.